Choosing The Right Bait: Tips And Tricks

For many hunters, bear baiting does not begin until it’s too late. In reality, some of the most important work happens much earlier. May and June are a critical window, when bears are active, covering ground, and establishing patterns that carry into fall. During this time, black bears are in their breeding season, and boars travel long distances in search of sows. That movement creates opportunity. A bait site established early can turn a passing bear into a repeat visitor. Starting bait sites in June, or earlier, gives you an advantage. Early baiting establishes a dependable food source and builds consistent patterns before natural foods take over. It also gives you time to figure out what your bears are responding to and adjust as the season progresses. What you put in your bait, and how you present it, plays a major role in whether bears stop or keep coming back.

Quick Bait Tips That Make a Big Difference:

• Not all bait is created equal, and what you choose should depend on how you access your site. If you are packing bait in, weight matters. Lighter options like cereals or popcorn are easier to haul. If you have an ATV or easy access, heavier, high-protein baits like nuts more closely match a bear’s natural diet and help keep them coming back.

• Quality matters. Bears have options, and if your bait is not appealing, they will move on. Using a bear mix, like our peanut butter bear mix, offers a variety of flavors that can appeal to even the pickiest bears.

• Toppings that are more water resistant, like frostings and peanut butters, are great when you’re expecting rain in the forecast. By topping your dry bait, you can help prevent it from getting soggy, since bears are much less interested in wet bait.

• Sticky bait works, even if it is a mess. Products like frosting, peanut butter, and syrups get scent and oils all over a bear’s fur and paws. When they leave, they track it back through the woods like a Hansel and Gretel crumb trail, helping lead other bears right back to your site.

• Scent is not the place to cut corners. A strong, consistent scent draws bears in from a distance. Once you choose one, stick with it and use it every time.

• If you are using a concentrate, mix it with cooking oil so it lasts longer and holds up in the weather.

Just Getting Started? Here’s What You Need:

Here’s what we recommend: three or four barrels (165 – 220 gallons) of at least two different varieties of a high-quality dry bait. Two to four different wet toppings (peanut butter is a go-to). And finally, strong sprayable scent mixed with oil (anise is a favorite).

Start simple and adjust as you go. How much you’ll need depends on when you start, how many sites you run, and how quickly bears are hitting your bait. Don’t be surprised if you need to restock sooner than expected. If you’re still unsure what you need, stop in and we’ll be happy to help you get set up.

We’ll be maintaining all of our same locations for 2026, including Appleton, Birnamwood, Tomahawk, Phelps, and Ishpeming, along with stocking bait at Superior Sport & Feed in Crystal Falls, Michigan.

To stay up to date on the latest news and sales, follow us on Facebook.

You can view our full lineup of bait and locations at bobsbearbait.com.

If you have questions or want to talk directly to Bob, you can reach him at sales@bobsbearbait.com or by phone at (920) 419-1238. Your one stop shop for all your baiting needs!